VizWiz

Actionable tips to launch, grow, and unlock your career in data

April 15, 2011

To mislead or not to mislead, that is the question

No comments

Have you ever received a chart similar to this? I did and was flabbergasted.  What disturbed me most was that it was intentionally misleading.  The other people who saw the chart didn’t notice the major problem that the dual-axes are not synchronized (and a dual-axis chart is unnecessary in this case anyway).

Dual-Axis Bad

I quickly corrected the chart and shared how it should look.  They were stunned at the the different stories these charts tell at first glance.

Dual-Axis Bad to Good

Bottom line: be skeptical when someone sends you a chart and quickly correct the situation if needed.  Take Mar-11 as an example:

  1. In the first chart it looks like Group E is only 2% better than Group Y
  2. In the second chart you can clearly see the gap is much, much bigger

Now take a quick look at Dec-10 (don’t cheat and look at the data).  In the 1st chart you’d think Group Y is killing Group E, when in fact Group E is outperforming Group Y.

It’s a scary world out there when people try to intentionally mislead you in an effort to support their personal agenda.  A friend of mine likes to say “Facts are friendly”.  Presenting facts needs to be friendly as well.

No comments

Post a Comment