Data Viz Done Right

July 19, 2017

Trump is Historically Unpopular

3 comments
On the train this morning I was catching up on some reading and ran across this post from FiveThirtyEight about Trump's approval rating compared to past presidents at the 175-day mark. In the article, there's this table of the ratings:


The table is ok in that it lists the presidents in descending order by net approval rating. However, I thought a visual display would be more effective. I used Google Sheets to import the table and quickly connected it to Tableau and built a slope graph to more effectively display the data.

It only took about 15 minutes to build this, so I'm surprised FiveThirtyEight didn't include a visual. I wonder what their reasoning is for including a chart vs. a table. What do you think? Which view works better for you?

3 comments :

  1. I am a fan of visuals, so thanks for whipping this cool example together. I will also say that an increasing slope that's actually communicating a decline over time was a bit tricky to read. Maybe another form would be better or five thirty eight could've kept it to approval rating at inauguration and 6 months later so the slope can compare apples to apples?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Fair point. I put disapprove before approve and it looked a bit weird. Maybe a simple bar chart of the net approval rating would be even better.

      Delete

    2. I like the bar chart idea.

      Maybe put approve/disapprove for each president next to each other and put the net approval above in a visually striking way (like you've done here)? With the actual approve and disapprove numbers inside wach bar, at the bottom or in the middle, in muted colors and smaller font.

      Delete